Comparing LED and Traditional Grow Lights for Your Greenhouse

Are you trying to decide between LED and traditional grow lights for your greenhouse? 

With so many varieties of LED and traditional grow lights, deciding on the best one for your greenhouse can be a bit overwhelming. 

Don't worry—we've got you covered! 

Let's explore everything you need to know about these lighting options to help you create the perfect environment for your plants.

1. Energy Efficiency and Cost

Ever wondered about the real cost difference between LED and traditional lights? Here's the scoop:

LED Lights

LED grow lights are known for their energy efficiency and are popular with gardeners who want long-term savings: 

  • Though initially more expensive, they can significantly reduce electricity costs over time. 
  • LEDs typically use up to 70% less power than traditional lights, making them an eco-friendly, cost-effective choice.

Jonathan Marsland, one of our happy customers, found that his 44" full-spectrum LED lights were especially efficient: "I’ve got three of them plugged together, and it works great for my greenhouse."

Traditional Lights

While these familiar options (like High-Pressure Sodium and fluorescent lights) are easier on your wallet initially, they'll take a bigger bite out of your monthly energy budget. 

Think of it as choosing between a fuel-efficient hybrid car and a conventional vehicle—sometimes spending more now means saving later!

2. Light Spectrum and Plant Growth

Creating the perfect growing environment is like conducting an orchestra – every element needs to work in harmony, and temperature is a crucial note to get right.

LED Lights

Imagine having the power to recreate natural sunlight right in your greenhouse! 

This adaptability allows you to mimic natural sunlight, enabling plants to thrive in a controlled environment.

LEDs are especially useful for growing plants with specific light needs at various stages, like seedlings or flowering plants.

Traditional Lights

While traditional lights can be effective, their spectrum is often limited. HPS lights, for instance, emit more red light, which benefits flowering stages but may lack the blue spectrum for vegetative growth. 

Fluorescent lights are great for seedlings and leafy greens but don’t offer the flexibility of LEDs for plants that require different spectrums.

3. Heat Output and Greenhouse Environment

You wouldn't want to spend all your time changing light bulbs when you could be tending to your plants, would you?

LED Lights

LED grow lights emit very little heat, beneficial in warm climates or tightly enclosed greenhouses where temperature control is crucial. 

Lower heat means a reduced need for additional cooling, allowing LEDs to shine in environments that demand careful heat management.

Traditional Lights

Traditional lighting, particularly HPS, generates significant heat. This can be advantageous in colder months, helping to maintain warmth in a greenhouse. 

Sheryl Pikaart-Kesti, one of our seasoned greenhouse gardeners, combines layers of protection with her grow lights in zone 4b, where temperatures can drop below 10 degrees Fahrenheit. 

She adds, “I use an oil heater on low 600w during evening and early morning, but the light also helps.”

4. Lifespan and Maintenance

Your greenhouse contributes to a greener future, so let's discuss how your lighting choice can help protect our planet.

LED Lights

LEDs are famous for their long lifespan, typically 50,000 hours or more, requiring less frequent replacement. 

This longevity reduces maintenance and replacement costs, making them a hassle-free option for busy gardeners.

Traditional Lights

Depending on usage, traditional grow lights generally need replacing every 1-2 years. 

Fluorescent lights, for instance, may need more frequent replacement if they are used daily, increasing maintenance costs and inconvenience.

5. Environmental Impact

After exploring all these factors, you're probably eager to choose and grow!

LED Lights

LEDs are more sustainable due to their low energy consumption and long lifespan. 

They’re also more recyclable and emit fewer pollutants over time, which can substantially reduce overall environmental impact, especially for commercial growers.

Traditional Lights

Traditional lighting systems are less eco-friendly, as they require more energy and must be replaced more often, leading to higher waste. 

Certain types, like HPS, may also contain less environmentally friendly materials, making disposal a consideration.

Let There Be Light! Your Perfect Greenhouse Lighting 

When choosing between LED and traditional grow lights, weighing each option’s long-term benefits against initial costs and specific greenhouse needs is essential. 

Ultimately, LEDs offer a versatile, energy-efficient option to enhance greenhouse productivity, especially for those looking to maximize growth in all seasons. 

So, whether you’re growing vegetables year-round or helping seedlings, both options have their place in a well-planned greenhouse. Explore our grow lights and start your gardening adventure!

Why Planta Greenhouses?

Back to Learn